Over 30 years Of Successfully Representing Clients
Photo of John B. Carlson

Can you refuse a breath test?

On Behalf of | May 15, 2025 | DUI

Getting stopped for suspected DUI creates a stressful and high-stakes situation. One of the first things an officer may ask is for you to take a breath test. But do you have the legal authority to refuse?

Implied consent rule

When you drive in Pennsylvania, you give implied consent to chemical testing if an officer suspects DUI. This legal principle means the state can penalize you for refusing a test, even if no DUI charges follow. Refusing may lead to serious consequences for your ability to drive.

What happens if you refuse?

Refusing a breath test results in an automatic suspension of your driver’s license. The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT) imposes a 12- to 18-month suspension, depending on your record. This penalty applies even if the DUI charge does not move forward.

You also risk facing steeper fines and more severe penalties in court. Judges often view a refusal as evidence of impairment. That perception can influence sentencing and make your legal outcome worse.

Police must follow procedures

Officers must clearly explain the legal consequences of refusing a breath test. If they fail to provide this information, courts may reject the refusal as valid. Police must also confirm that you understood the warning. In some cases, courts have sided with drivers when officers skipped key steps or gave confusing instructions.

Should you refuse a breath test?

Although refusing may seem like a way to protect yourself, it usually increases your legal trouble. A refusal does not block DUI prosecution. Instead, it adds more penalties and complicates your case. Understanding your rights matters, but so does recognizing the risks of refusing a test.